October 23, 2012

D'Oh!!! The Dumb Things That Lawyers Do with Their E-Mail

Issue Cover Law Practice Magazine Logo


Say so long to your comfort zone.
What you need to know
about managing the multigenerational law firm.

June 2006 Issue | Volume 32 Number 4 | Page 20

Hot Buttons

By Sharon Nelson and John Simek

Even Homer Simpson might be appalled at what lawyers do with their e-mail. We've compiled a list of fixes to our top 10 favorite gripes to share with you here. If you're e-mail savvy, perhaps none of these mistakes are yours. But if you do see yourself in the following list, it might be time to polish your 'Net manners.


Top 10 Solutions to E-mail Gripes


1. Check the spelling and grammar. Would you send out something full of misspellings or grammatical errors on your letterhead? Most surely, you would not. No lawyer wants his or her correspondence to look unprofessional. But in a frantic, pressed-for-time world, lawyers are increasingly conducting their business via e-mail. Nothing inherently wrong with that, but for heaven's sake, turn on the spelling and grammar checker and proof your e-mail before you hit Send. We've received e-mails from lawyers with so many misspellings and errors that it's hard to conceive they graduated from high school, much less law school.


2. Get your own domain. We continue to receive e-mails from joeqlawyer@aol.com,

jillqlawyer@yahoo.com and the like. If you haven't figured it out yet, let us be crystal clear: Today's more sophisticated clients have disdain for lawyers so far behind the times that they don't have their own domains. For mere pennies (at least figuratively), lawyers can own their own domain. And guess what? If you have an AOL, Yahoo, Hotmail or similar account and you (or they) decide to cancel it—or the company happens to belly up—you don't have a transportable domain and must ensure that all clients have your new e-mail address. E-mails sent to your old address will vanish into the electronic void. On the other hand, when you own the domain smartlawyer.com, you can travel merrily from ISP to ISP with your e-mail address of dudleydoright@smartlawyer.com.


3. Remember that e-mail lives forever. We've read highly entertaining e-mails from lawyers who were thoroughly ticked off. Make a note to yourself: "I will not e-mail anyone when I am angry." First, you're likely to say something that will come back and bite you. Second, what you say in anger and what you will say after a cool-down period are two different things—and the cooled-down reply is likely to be the smartest play. Lastly, e-mail does not vanish. It's on your backup tapes, the person who received it may save or forward it, and the like. Worst of all, it may turn out to be the subject of litigation. We always tell clients, "Ask yourself: Is it okay with you if your e-mail is on the front page of your local newspaper? If not, don't send it." Which brings us to the Mom Rule next.


4. Don't hit Send unless it's okay if mom reads it. There are some activities that don't belong on a business e-mail system. If you can't figure out what, you're too young to be reading this magazine. Business e-mail may be monitored by your law firm. It may turn out to be the subject of discovery in a malpractice or other lawsuit. The person you're e-mailing may not guard your privacy as you would. You may, even with security on your network, have spyware on your machine monitoring your activities. This Mom Rule applies more generally to all personal e-mail (and not just the "R" or "X" rated stuff). This is the perfect place to get a free Hotmail, G-Mail or Yahoo account to conduct your personal business (including your financial transactions!) to make sure that what is personal stays personal. But even with this personal account, remember that there's inherent danger of disclosure using the personal account in a business setting. At home, you control your own security and you do not need to consider whether your activities online are being monitored by an employer.


5. Look carefully at the recipient name before you hit Send. This is particularly true if you use the auto-complete feature of your e-mail program, where you start typing "jo" in the To line and it cheerfully offers you johnsmith@yahoo.com,whom you write to often. However, if you meant to write johnsutton@lawfirm.com, this can be a big boo-boo. Herewith a cautionary tale from one of the authors, who wrote a testy, slightly threatening e-mail to an attorney who had failed to comply with discovery requests. Unfortunately, it was misaddressed to an attorney with a similar name, who demanded to know what the heck the author was talking about. Profuse apologies behind her, your heroine finally got the right name. One more tale, which we will tell discreetly to protect our "R" rating: A partner at a local firm was having an affair with an associate. He e-mailed her with his plans for the night at a hotel rendezvous. These plans included various oils, mechanical devices and a set of handcuffs. Unfortunately, in his erotic euphoria, he goofed and sent the e-mail to the entire firm via an e-mail distribution list. It didn't turn out to be such a great night after all.


6. Remember that you have a BCC field. Not everyone loves to have their e-mail addresses shared, and it is a clear violation of "Netiquette" to do so. If you want to send holiday messages to your clients, fine, but their addresses should go in the BCC (blind carbon copy) field. Not only do folks get irritated by having their addresses shared with total strangers—it also results in more spam as their e-mail addresses, without their consent, are now on other peoples' hard drives ready for the bots, worms, viruses and Trojans of the world to exploit. There is a notable exception to this guideline: If you are working with a group of folks at your firm, obviously having e-mail addresses visible is a good thing since they can hit Reply All. The same applies to bar committees and the like, where Reply All is a desirable feature.


7. Have a well-designed signature block. Hey, this is free advertising! And the best "branding" you can get. This is Your Name, over and over, putting small wrinkles in the gray matter of your clients' and colleagues' brains. Here too, close at hand, is all your contact info so they can send you a letter or a fax or visit your Web site. Virtually all e-mail programs now make it simple to create a signature block. Simply type "signature" in your e-mail program's Help and you'll be good to go in no time.


8. Don't send out metadata unless you intend to. Ah, but lawyers are a slapdash bunch. You need to send a document to a client, you attach it to your e-mail and through the magic of the 'Net, it is almost instantly at your client's fingertips. But unless you've scrubbed the document of its metadata, your client (or heaven forbid, you sent something to opposing counsel!) can plainly see who authored the document; how many revisions it went through; who saved it last; when it was last printed; and, if they have the right software, the entire chain of authorship, complete with comments and revisions. How do you avoid this? You can PDF it, which will strip out almost all the metadata, or you can use a metadata scrubber. Our favorite is Metadata Assistant from www.payneconsulting.com, which runs about $80 per user. It is idiot-proof (one of the authors knows this, being a lawyer herself). When you go to transmit a document, Metadata Assistant pops up a box saying, in effect, "Wait a moment, you chowderhead! Are you sure you want to send this without cleaning it?"


9. Think carefully before you engage in substantive conversation. E-mail is fine for setting up appointments, advising clients of court dates and the like, but do you really want to conduct substantive business that way? We've seen countless cases where attorney-client correspondence was monitored by spyware. Can you afford to take that risk? Is it prudent to discuss things via e-mail, especially sensitive things, when one never knows what a client might say? The whole concept is rife with potential ethical problems. Imagine a criminal attorney who, after corresponding with his client, gets a late-night e-mail from the client, who has had too much wine, confessing in maudlin regret to a crime. Or an angry client who decides that your e-mail needs to be shipped off to a disciplinary board with a complaint. If it can happen, it will, though hopefully not to you.

Five good practice tips:

  • Say nothing substantive until you have a retainer agreement in place. Make sure any e-mail you send to a prospective client says that there is no attorney-client relationship in place until there is a retainer agreement.

  • Make sure the retainer agreement addresses e-mail. It is prudent to have a separate clause, which the client initials, stating that the client authorizes the use of e-mail in his or her case and understands that sensitive subjects should not be addressed in e-mail. Highlighting this clause in some manner and having a separate set of initials may help you down the road if the client ignores your advice.

  • Follow your own advice. E-mail is fast and easy. Its allure can be seductive. However, it is often better and safer to pick up the phone and confer.

  • If you're going to be away, use an "Out of the Office" message. Most e-mail packages allow you to set up an out-of-office message that goes out automatically when someone sends an e-mail while you're away. At least the client will know why you cannot respond to his or her message all that quickly. If this type of auto-reply is not possible with your e-mail configuration, you may want to actively notify clients prior to being unavailable that you will not have access to your e-mail.

  • What's your e-mail response time? This is another sore spot with clients, and suggests another clause that you should probably insert in the retainer agreement. Set the client's expectations by saying something along the lines of, "I will attempt to respond to all e-mail within 24 hours or to let you know if I am out of the office or otherwise unavailable." Clients get accustomed to the immediate gratification of e-mail, so it is best to set their expectations early on.


10. E-mail is great for business development—use it! E-mail is a splendid marketing tool, and too rarely used with that intent. You never, ever, want to use it for spam, of course, but keeping your name in front of clients and colleagues is very important for future business and for referrals. In today's electronic world, it is perfectly acceptable to send birthday or holiday wishes via e-mail. We frequently use it to say a warm hello to a client after a case is closed and to express our hope that we'll be able to work together again. If something crosses our desks that might interest a client, we forward it on. We use our Contacts in Outlook to keep records of the names of spouses and children and other facts of interest. Since we suffer from the classic malady CRS (Can't Remember Stuff … well, it's something like that), our database of information is invaluable. If an old client calls up out of the blue, we can quickly pull up the client in Contacts and ask about the kids by name. They really like it that you "remembered." (For goodness sake, don't give your database secret away!) Likewise, when you want to send an e-mail to a group of clients, perhaps because of a new development in the law that they need to know about, it is simplicity itself to write an e-mail to a group, selecting the group's members from your Contacts list.

Just remember number 6 on our list and use the BCC field for the addresses!


Welcome to a Wonderful World (Warts and All)

So, there you have it, a top 10 list for the 21st century lawyer. We have finally reached the point where virtually all lawyers have succumbed to our times and now use e-mail. Although there were a lot just five years ago who swore they never would, we're down to just a handful of stragglers still resisting.

Of course, as the electronic world has become the norm, it has also brought new ethical and professional considerations with it. E-mail can be a trap for the unwary—but it is an enormous boon to those who use it effectively.