Vol. 42, No. 3

Judicial Independence in a Partisan Nation: Courting or Combating Politicization?

Is there any aspect of our republic more essential to its effectiveness and continuity than the independence of our nation’s courts and their ability to uphold the Rule of Law?

Increasing contentiousness in the confirmation of federal district and circuit judges, as evidenced by declining confirmation rates and growing lengths of time between nomination and confirmation, is a byproduct of the political polarization that has limited the federal government’s ability to perform basic functions.

State courts play a vital role in our democracy. Recent empirical studies have shown that state court judges today are under terrific pressure to be accountable to political forces rather than the state and federal constitutions and laws.

Particularly when consumers or employees are up against corporations, the right of access to the courts has not been upheld and given the attention needed from the Supreme Court.

The money flooding into state judicial elections pressures judges to favor their own party in deciding election disputes. This trend is a threat to democracy and a warning sign that powerful interest groups may have succeeded in using campaign money to undermine impartial justice.

Like the cycle of poverty, those who are poor and caught up in the criminal legal system can find it a nearly impossible pattern to break. Often beginning from unpaid fines, jail sentences can grow exponentially for those who don’t have the means to pay fines or seek representation.

To understand the issues before them, judges must be somewhat technologically savvy, but there currently exists a distance of use and application and a lack of knowledge of technology among our country’s judges.

The role of tribal courts continues to be misunderstood and undermined as a serious judicial structure, particularly in cases where a non-Indian is involved.

Throughout history, the severity with which children are punished has varied in the criminal justice system. Currently, there is a commitment to trying children in a separate juvenile justice system instead of with adults, and hopefully this trend continues.

Abner J. Mikva, who died last year, was a believer in the courts and in the profound role judges should play. Above all, he said, judges must possess courage, especially to protect rights and serve as a check on government power.

Human Rights Magazine

Each of our Section members receives a subscription to Human Rights, our award-winning quarterly magazine. For decades, it has been a trusted source of expert ideas, opinions, and discourse on a diverse array of topics in the human and civil rights arena.

About the Magazine

Published quarterly, Human Rights covers a wide range of topics in the human and civil rights arena. While the subscription is free of charge for Section members, individual subscriptions may be purchased for $18 by calling the American Bar Association Service Center at 1-800-285-2221. Additional annual subscriptions for Section members are $3 each.

If you are a member of the ABA but not the Section of Individual Rights and Responsibilities then we encourage you to join today. If you are not a member of the ABA then we encourage you to visit the ABA membership page. You can also resolve membership issues by calling 1-800-285-2221.

Please note that all information appears as it did when originally published. Therefore, some biographical information about the authors may no longer be accurate.

Editorial Board

Chair Wilson Adam Schooley

Kristen Galles
Jason Miller
Serena Nowell
Claire Parins
Aram A. Schvey
Jason Sengheiser
Juan Thomas
Penny Wakefield
Stephen J. Wermiel
Alex Wohl

Issue Editors
Wilson Adam Schooley
Misty Thomas
Seth Miller

Section of Civil Rights and Social Justice

Chair Kirke Kickingbird
Chair-elect Robert N. Weiner
Vice-Chair Wilson Adam Schooley
Secretary Sheila Y. Thomas
Finance Officer Toby Graff
Section Delegate Estelle H. Rogers
Section Delegate Walter H. White, Jr.
Immediate Past Chair Lauren Stiller Rikleen
Section Director Tanya N. Terrell
Associate Director Paula Shapiro
Project Director (AIDS) and Director of the ABA Center for Human Rights Michael L. Pates
Project Director (Death Penalty Due Process Review) Misty Thomas
Section Administrator Jaime T. Campbell
Program Assistant Alli Kielsgard

Copyright Information

All articles and information on this page are copyright 2017 by the American Bar Association. All rights reserved. This information or any portion thereof may not be copied or disseminated in any form or by any means or stored in an electronic database or retrieval system without the express written consent of the American Bar Association.

Request Reprint Permission