Criminal Justice Section

Criminal Justice Magazine, Spring 2008 (Vol. 23/ No. 1)


(Access to articles are limited to ABA members.)


Cross-Racial Identification of Defendants in Criminal Cases: A Proposed Model Jury Instruction By David E. Aaronson

Erroneous eyewitness identification is the single leading cause of wrongful conviction in the United States, and studies indicate most of the faulty identifications have a racial component. Prof. David Aaronson authored a book on Maryland’s criminal jury instructions and here he makes the case for a model instruction that cautions jurors to consider the possibility of erroneous eyewitness identification, especially when the eyewitness and the defendant are of different races and when such iden-tification is the primary evidence against the accused. In addition, he reviews those jurisdictions that currently employ a cross-racial identification jury instruction, as well as the arguments opposing it.

Advising the Grand Jury Witness When Talk Is Not Cheap By Jon May

Preparing a client who has been subpoenaed by a grand jury is daunting; not know-ing what went on behind the closed doors can be devastating. Clients are not always able—or willing— to recount their own testimony, so obtaining a transcript is invalu-able. But not all courts agree. Following a typical scenario with a less-than-ideal client, the author suggests how to prep for the grand jury appearance and outlines what options are available in acquiring access to that all-important transcript.

The American Prosecutor: Power, Discretion, and Misconduct By Angela J. Davis (This article is not available in electronic format.)

Prof. Davis (American University School of Law) examines in this excerpt from her book, Arbitrary Justice, the dangers that reside in the exercise of unchecked power by today’s prosecutors. A one-time public defender, the author is deeply troubled by the abuses she witnessed—from the use of minimum sentences in order to force plea bargains to unfair and uneven charging—by attorneys who confuse winning with justice. Acknowledging the need for discretion in the prosecutorial process, Davis ar-gues for better and more stringent oversight. In this excerpt she reviews the breadth of the problem and looks at a complicity within the courts that results in a lack of consequences for prosecutors who cross the line.


Chair’s Counsel: Changes To Model Rules Impact Prosecutors

Cert Alert: U.S. Supreme Court Accepts 12 New Cases

Ethics: New Rules for Scientific and Exculpatory Evidence

Federal Sentencing: Supreme Court Finally Fulfills Promise

Trial Tactics: Pejorative Closing Arguments

Rules Alert: Criminal Rules Amendments Effective as of Dec. 2007

Section News

Criminal Justice Magazine

Criminal Justice magazine, published quarterly by the Criminal Justice Section of the American Bar Association, is intended for a national audience of defense lawyers, prosecutors, judges, academics, and other criminal justice professionals with a focus on the practice and policy issues of the criminal justice system. Each issue includes feature articles, as well as regular columns. In addition, there are occasional thematic issues which focus on one particular aspect of the criminal justice system.

For more information on subscriptions, back issues, editorial policy, guidelines for authors and contributors, or advertising, please visit the magazine information page.

Copyright American Bar Association.

American Bar Association

American Bar Association | 740 15th Street, N.W. | Washington, DC 20005-1019 | 202.662.1000
ABA Copyright Statement   ABA Privacy Statement