YourABA December 2011 Masthead

Private lawyers doing government work should have qualified immunity, ABA urges Supreme Court

In an amicus brief filed in Filarsky v. Delia, the American Bar Association is urging the U.S. Supreme Court to protect the public interest by ruling that outside lawyers retained by public entities to do government legal work are entitled to the same immunity from related lawsuits that government employees have.

Steve A. Filarsky, a private lawyer, was retained by the City of Rialto, Calif., to provide labor and employment law guidance in an investigation involving firefighter Nicholas B. Delia. When Delia later sued the city, its personnel and Filarsky for civil rights violations, all defendants asserted qualified immunity, which the district court granted. The Ninth Circuit reversed as to Filarsky, concluding that he was not entitled to qualified immunity based on his status as a private lawyer.

The ABA is asking the justices to overturn the Ninth Circuit's reversal. Oral arguments are scheduled for Jan. 17.

"State and local governments frequently must retain private counsel for the effective and efficient performance of core governmental functions," the ABA brief states. Denying qualified immunity to outside lawyers from lawsuits stemming from their government work would deter them from representing public entities and "significantly impact the vital contributions that private attorneys make to effective government performance. On the other hand, ensuring qualified immunity would promote the strong public interest in the continuing representation of public entities by private counsel," the ABA concludes.

The brief, which was proposed by the ABA Section of State and Local Government Law, is available here.

Back to top



A day in the life…


Public Wi-Fi and the cost of "free"


Better legal writing now: Top mistakes to avoid; tips on nurturing young talent; more


High-profile litigators on high-profile cases in media

Dos and Don’ts for LinkedIn success

State rules leave virtual law offices vulnerable to misconduct

Court best practices for avoiding a “mistrial by Google”

Providing benefits to same-sex spouses of employees: Legal issues, best practices

A new day for the Office of Special Counsel, say panelists at ABA program

Global risks report on today’s changing landscape

Advice on working for Uncle Sam

ABA files amicus brief in Filarsky v. Delia


Maximize your membership: Join an ABA section, division or forum