August 06, 2019 Practice Points

Second Circuit Creates Split on Investment Company Act Private Right of Action

We will have to wait and see how other courts may weigh in, and whether or not the Supreme Court will ultimately resolve the split.

By Gabriel Gillett and Howard Suskin

In a decision issued on August 5, 2019, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit created a split with other courts, including the Third Circuit, on the issue of whether there is a private right of action for rescission under the Investment Company Act (ICA). The Second Circuit held that, based on the text of the statute and its legislative history, “ICA § 47(b)(2) creates an implied private right of action for a party to a contract that violates the ICA to seek rescission of that violative contract.” Oxford University Bank v. Lansuppe Feeder Inc., No. 16-4061 (2d Cir. Aug. 5, 2019), Slip op. 23. In so holding, the court acknowledged that it was creating a circuit split:

We note that the Third Circuit and several lower courts have reached the opposite result. In Santomenno ex rel. John Hancock Trust v. John Hancock Life Ins. Co., 677 F.3d 178 (3d Cir. 2012), the Third Circuit found plaintiffs lacked a private right of action to seek rescission under § 47(b). Plaintiffs in Santomenno alleged violations of ICA § 26(f), which makes it unlawful to pay “fees and charges” on certain insurance contracts that exceed what is “reasonable,” id. at 187, and sought rescission (in addition to monetary damages). The court in Santomenno found that plaintiffs did not have a cause of action. We do not find the reasoning in Santomenno persuasive. 

Slip op. 21-22.

Litigators should watch to see how other courts weigh in and whether the Supreme Court ultimately takes up the issue to resolve the split.

Gabriel Gillett is an associate and Howard Suskin is a partner at Jenner & Block LLP in Chicago, Illinois. 


Copyright © 2019, American Bar Association. All rights reserved. This information or any portion thereof may not be copied or disseminated in any form or by any means or downloaded or stored in an electronic database or retrieval system without the express written consent of the American Bar Association. The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the positions or policies of the American Bar Association, the Section of Litigation, this committee, or the employer(s) of the author(s).