chevron-down Created with Sketch Beta.
Public Defense News

Public Defense News Archive

Here you will find current public defense news, as well as past news archived reverse chronologically. The ABA does not maintain external links.
Report a Broken Link

March 2025

3/12/25

The 2025 ABA Public Defense Summit is coming on April 4 and 5! There’s still plenty of time to register. We hope to see you there, in person or virtually. Connect with other public defenders, knock out most of your CLE requirements, and learn about some of the major issues in public defense from top experts.

Last week’s newsletter went out on Friday, and public defense-related news has been light lately, so this is a short one. But look for an important court ruling out of Maine.

Alabama:

60 years after Bloody Sunday in Alabama, elusive racial progress in Selma

California:

California’s Effort to Reduce, Overturn Unjust Prison Sentences

San Francisco Public Defenders Win Landmark Racial Justice Act Case

Louisiana:

Five Louisiana public defenders to be removed from positions in July

Maine:

Kennebec County Superior Court rules Maine is violating Sixth Amendment

Maine must release people from jail, drop charges if no lawyer available, justice rules

Penobscot County public defenders receiving pressure to take on more cases

Oregon:

Editorial: Budget plan for public defense crisis will help, not solve

VIDEO: Pressure mounts for Oregon to course-correct on plans to reform public defense system

West Virginia:

Mingo County Commission recognizes public defenders; gives funds to hospital

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How the San Mateo Private Defender Program is Trying to Earn Back the Community's Trust w/Lisa Maguire and Harpreet Samra

How Sec Def Austin Interfered with the 9/11 and U.S.S. Cole Case Plea Deals w/Allison Miller and Katie Carmon

3/7/25

The 2025 ABA Public Defense Summit is a month away! We hope to see you there, in person or virtually. Connect with other public defenders, knock out most of your CLE requirements, and learn about some of the major issues in public defense from top experts.

California:

Justice and Public Safety Forum Provides New Insights Into Shasta County Challenges

Low salaries, staffing woes, 'crushing' workloads: public safety trouble in Shasta County

Connecticut:

Derby public defender withdraws from consideration for Superior Court bench, officials say

Iowa:

Overworked and underpaid: the indigent defense shortage in Iowa persists

Louisiana:

5 chief public defenders told they will lose jobs following Landry board takeover

Maine:

Opinion: How to really tackle Maine’s indigent defense crisis

Mississippi:

Proposed public defender pilot program aims to better represent indigent defendants in Mississippi

Senate reduces indigent counsel fee increases proposed by House

Nevada:

Bill requires judicial candidates have trial experience, seeks end to secrecy of judicial discipline

New Jersey:

New Jersey Office of the Public Defender Unveils Collaborative, Holistic Representation Model to Address the Complex Needs of Individuals in the Criminal Legal System

Ohio:

Putnam commissioners discuss possibility of initiating public defender option

Oregon:

Oregon lawmakers scramble for solutions to public defender crisis

Marion County judge warns she may start forcing public defenders to take more cases

Of Interest:

Public Defense: Partners for Justice Hopes to Change the Field With Young Advocates Who Stand Up for Their Clients

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

Was a Former Colorado Public Defender Fired for Raising Concerns over his Workload? w/Travis Weiner

How The American Eugenics Movement Helped Create Habitual Offender Laws w/Daniel Loehr

February 2025

2/28/25

The time to lock in your early bird rate for ABA Public Defense Summit ends on Monday, March 3! Note that virtual attendance is also an option for those who can’t make the trip to Chicago. Many speakers have been announced. Take a look at the speaker page on the above registration link.

Alabama:

Speedy Trial Act bill introduced in Senate

California:

Public defender says Alameda court strike led to rights violations

Judge admonished for 'undignified' behavior, including gestures mimicking pumping of breast milk

Louisiana:

A former criminal judge known as a public defense advocate is running for New Orleans mayor

Maine:

Prosecutors say it’s not just public defense agencies that are struggling to hire over low pay

Maine’s top judge questions why Janet Mills hasn’t filled open judicial seat

Maine owes it to citizens to properly resource judicial branch, chief justice says

Michigan:

Eve Primus Delivers “Blue Jeans” Lecture on Fighting for Systemic Change

Mississippi:

Indigent counsel fees could soon be increased in Mississippi

Missouri:

Public defender’s office draws outrage from Missouri GOP leaders over hiring convicted felon

Missouri public defender fires convicted felon to move budget forward

New York:

Constantia man’s case delayed again due to lack of lawyer

Nebraska:

Fye named Seward County public defender

North Carolina:

Chief public defenders tapped for two districts

North Dakota:

North Dakota House Passes Bill To Expand Marijuana Decriminalization, Making Low-Level Possession A $150 Citation

Oregon:

Oregon’s latest plan to reduce public defense crisis makes it worse, analysis says (partial paywall)

Lawmaker loses confidence in public defense leader, calls for National Guard response

Oregon’s chief justice tells judges to stay out of public defense politics as she fights for pay raises

Pennsylvania:

Editorial: O'Connor audit shows, once again, that indigent defense is floundering in Allegheny County

South Dakota:

Brown County hires first chief public defender to head new office (partial paywall)

Pilot program will allow new lawyers to swap public service for South Dakota bar exam

Texas:

A shortage of criminal defense attorneys threatens indigent right to counsel in rural Texas

Washington:

Okanogan County’s new Office of Public Defender begins to take shape

Mountlake Terrace City council passes public defender agreement, 5-1

Of Interest:

Legal Agitator of Our Time (Book Review)

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

The Coalition Fighting to Save New York's Discovery Laws w/Amanda Jack and Kalle Condliffe

How the Far West Texas Public Defenders Uncovered a Pattern of Discovery Violations in El Paso w/James McDermott and Paul Chambers

2/19/25

Registration for the ABA Public Defense Summit is now live! Register by March 3 to lock in your early bird rate, and note that there is a 20 percent discount for group registrations. For those who attend in person, this will be a great way to connect with public defense professionals from around the country in a time of new challenges. Virtual attendance is also an option for those who can’t make the trip to Chicago.

As we typically see when during periods of time where are a lot of major ongoing national news stories, this is a light week for public defense news. We expect this trend will continue until the chaos relents. 

National:

Trump: Ex-Death Row Inmates To Live In 'Monstrous' Conditions

California:

I’m 1 of More Than 600 People on CA’s Death Row. Newsom Must End Death Penalty.

Florida:

FACDL and Florida Justice Center unveil clothing closet to aid indigent clients

Maine:

Douglas Rooks: More money is not the answer for Maine’s indigent defense cases

Michigan:

Frustrations continue for attorneys billing Wayne County Indigent Defense Services Department

Mississippi:

Search Mississippi Criminal Justice Bills as They Move Through the Legislature

Missouri:

Public defender’s office draws outrage from Missouri GOP leaders over hiring convicted felon

New Jersey:

Human rights group protests inequities in children getting tried as adults

New York:

Fully funding NYC public transit could reduce fare evasion, crime

Questions linger about public defender's office moves (Niagara County)

Oklahoma:

Stitt Calls for $1.4B Reduction in Budget

North Dakota:

Bill Would Reduce Penalties For Small Amounts of Marijuana in North Dakota

Ohio:

Monroe County commissioners freeze payments, appointments for lawyer who invoiced for $600,000

Richland County may create public defender's office

Oregon:

Deschutes County DA, judge say public defender shortage solved locally, urge state changes

Pennsylvania:

Opinion: Investing in public defenders is essential for justice to be served

Allegheny County public defense system needs major investments, says O'Connor audit

Wisconsin:

State Bar of Wisconsin: Presidents’ comments on funding for civil legal aid and criminal justice funding in Governor’s budget

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How the Laken Riley Act Could Get Innocent People Sent to Guantanamo Bay w/Ann Block and Nithya Nathan-Pineau

Prosecutorial Reform and the Myth of Individualized Enforcement w/Justin Murray

The Fight to Reform Oklahoma's Failure to Protect Laws w/Alexandra Bailey and Cindy Nguyen

2/12/25

Registration for the ABA Public Defense Summit is now live! Register by March 3 to lock in your early bird rate, and note that there is a 20 percent discount for group registrations. For those who attend in person, this will be a great way to connect with public defense professionals from around the country in a time of new challenges. Virtual attendance is also an option for those who can’t make the trip to Chicago.

Arizona:

Pinal County public defender's office staff recognized

California:

South Bay’s longest-serving public defender reflects on tenure as office looks ahead

Connecticut:

Lamont proposes criminal justice cuts: free messages for CT inmates, public defender access at stake

Georgia:

Coweta attorney Brian Lewis appointed to Public Defender Supervisory Panel

Indiana:

Hancock County weighs cost of public defender’s office

Kansas:

A shortage of public defense attorneys in Kansas could result in courts throwing out criminal cases

Kentucky:

KY lawmakers propose alternatives to incarceration for primary caregivers

New Jersey:

N.J. governor’s big plan to overhaul parole system and give second chances

New Mexico:

House Judiciary approves two public safety bills over the weekend

Oklahoma:

Stitt Calls for $1.4B Reduction in Budget

Ohio:

Commissioners discuss zoning fees, public defenders

Oregon:

Pragmatic Prosecutors: Multnomah County district attorney breaks with predecessor, says all crimes will be charged

Is there a public defender shortage in Oregon, or is there a 'work stoppage' as the Multnomah County DA claims?

DAs to lawmakers: Accused child rapist, killers, drug traffickers released from jail as cases stall with no public defenders

Pennsylvania:

Opinion: Investing in public defenders is essential for justice to be served

Public Defender Shortage in PA Sparks Hiring Push

Vermont:

Maggie Chavez: Lack of public defense resources necessitates a deeper exploration of restorative Justice

International:

Liberia: Same Faces Every Court Term, Public Defender Decry of Recycle Jurors

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How Cuyahoga County Jail Keeps Prisoners from their Family and Records their Conversations w/Nikki Baszynski

Should we Have Universal Public Defense w/Alexis Hoag-Fordjour

2/5/25

Registration for the ABA Public Defense Summit is now live! Join us on April 4 and 5, in person or virtually, at Chicago’s Northwestern University School of Law for a discussion of important and emerging issues in public defense while earning 9 hours of CLE credit (including 1.5 ethics).  Speakers will be announced soon. Take advantage of the early bird deadline to lock in a preferred rate before March 3!

California:

Yuba County celebrates first graduate of new Behavioral Health Court

Georgia:

Fulton County courts clear 93 percent of case backlog

Judge to seat jury in trial of ex-prosecutor accused of shielding Ahmaud Arbery’s killers

Idaho:

Idaho's public defense system asks lawmakers for dozens of new attorneys

Idaho public defender’s proposed budget seeks increases to address defense in rural counties

New public defense office fields JFAC questions

Illinois:

Champaign County Public Defender’s Office is facing a funding crisis after tax referendum fails

Maine:

Lawmaker hopes to alleviate attorney backlog by changing how Maine punishes bail violations

‘There is no increased risk to the public’: Maine Democrat Wants to Repeal the Crime of Violating Bail to Reduce Case Backlog

Gov. Mills doubles down on urging Maine’s public defense agency to relax rules

Public defense attorney says other agencies need to help fix Maine's legal backlog

ABA Journal: Should defendants without court-appointed lawyers be released? Should charges be dropped? Judge weighs remedies

Maine struggles with public defender crisis as costs soar and backlog increases

Massachusetts:

Letter: Access to justice means confronting bar advocate burnout

Minnesota:

Minnesota courts on notice as Laken Riley Act, targeted ICE enforcements go into effect

New York:

Queens Defenders' board forces out controversial executive director

Queens Defenders gets new interim executive director amid leadership shakeup

Legal costs for public defender's office probe topped $20,000 (Niagara Co.)

Ohio:

FULTON COUNTY COMMISSIONERS: Recent Indigent Defense Contract Approved

Summit Legal Defenders office expands services, changes locations

Oregon:

Oregon’s public defense crisis: Why thousands go without lawyers, jeopardizing cases

Opinion: Move past rhetoric to find real solutions to public defender crisis

Editorial: Oregon's public defense crisis is predicted to get worse

Pennsylvania:

Public defender shortage in PA sparks hiring push

Lebanon County DA faces backlash as NAACP condemns explosive remarks

Texas:

Texas Fair Defense Fund helps people get legal aid. Migrants are primary recipients: chief.

High Plains Regional Public Defender's Office makes progress with hires, Hale County office location

Vermont:

Where have all the public defenders gone?

Washington:

WA counties want big money to address public defender crisis

Pierce County Council sets legislative priorities

Rep. Debra Entenman’s Conversation With Larry Jefferson, Director Of The Office Of Public Defense

Wyoming:

Wyoming lawyers step up amid public defender shortage

Of Interest:

Paying for the Right to Counsel: National Survey Findings on the Practice of Charging Public Defense Fees to Clients

11 ABA advocacy wins from the 118th Congress

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How One Inconsistent Eye Witness Led to the Wrongful Conviction of Ivery Dorsey w/Kerrie Liang

The Impact of and the Resistance to Mass Deportation Policies w/Hans Meyer and Holly Lucas

Is Kansas Public Defense on the Verge of a Crisis? w/Heather Cessna

The Fight to End Youth Shackling and Limit Mass Surveillance in Virginia w/Rob Poggenklass and Bryan Kennedy

January 2025

1/27/25

Registration for the ABA Public Defense Summit is now live! Join us on April 4 and 5 at Chicago’s Northwestern University School of Law for a discussion of important and emerging issues in public defense. This is a hybrid conference, so you can register for the virtual option if you can’t make the trip. Speakers will be announced soon.

It’s a rare Monday newsletter! We hope to be back to the usual Wednesday schedule next week.

California:

LA County’s innovative effort to address public defender conflicts wins plaudits (partial paywall)

Florida:

For the first time in decades, Hillsborough County has a new public defender

'Giant shoes to fill': Daniel Eisinger sworn in as Palm Beach County's new public defender

Georgia:

Troup approves contract with new public defender

Indiana:

Steuben County keeps plugging away at public defender expansion

Public defender implores county council for staff raises (Hancock Co.)

Iowa:

Iowa’s chief justice asks lawmakers for magistrate system changes, judicial pay increases

Louisiana:

Professor Katherine Mattes, key player in Louisiana criminal justice reform, to retire

Maine:

District public defenders: Keeping our promises under the 6th Amendment

ACLU, state conclude arguments in indigent defense trial

Indigent defense trial continues in Augusta

What you need to know about the lawsuit over Maine's public defense system

Indigent defense lawsuit underway in Kennebec County

ACLU says lack of public defense lawyers in Maine erodes trust in courts

Experts talk indigent defense in January ‘radio hour’

Maine public defense agency urges state to fully fund its work

ACLU Asks Maine To Free Jail Inmates Until Counsel Is Available

Maryland:

Public defender, advocates push for Maryland to end automatic charging of youths as adults

Nevada:

New Nevada State Public Defender appointed

New York:

Gov leaves out atty student loan relief from budget

Love it or hate it, New York’s hotly debated bail reform law just turned 5

Public defenders argue their own case (Rochester)

Bronx Defenders form alliance to protect New York evidence sharing requirements

North Dakota:

Port: Indigent defense in North Dakota 'perilously close to a constitutional failure'

Oregon:

Multnomah County public defenders push back against new DA’s comments

Opinion: DA Vasquez is right. The public defense ‘crisis’ is a work stoppage

Pennsylvania:

Frequently Asked Questions About ACLU-PA's Indigent Defense Lawsuit

South Carolina:

Beaufort issues RFP for Indigent legal defense service

South Dakota:

Chief justice says SD would benefit from expanding its new criminal public defense office

Texas:

Rural Texas needs more public defenders. A state commission wants nearly $44M to help

New updates on public defender's office during commissioners court (Victoria)

Virginia:

Bill would expand access to Virginia public defenders, increase prosecutors’ workload

Washington:

Fulmer is concerned about indigent defense costs

Wisconsin:

Lawsuit remains, as Wisconsin public defender shortage persists

Wyoming:

Wyoming Prosecutors Say Widespread Lawyer Shortage Hurting Them Too

Of Interest:

Federal Public Defender Submits Brief with Nonexistent Citation, Apparently Refuses to Admit This to the Judge at a Hearing

Accessing public defender laptop to send ‘prank’ email costs Jefferson County APA his law license

Report: Public Defense Fees Can Make Justice Unaffordable

International:

Liberia: Public Defense Lawyers Get New Leadership, Pledges Transformation and Accountability

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How to Fight and Abolish the Death Penalty Outside of the Courtroom w/Abraham Bonowitz

How Pueblo Municipal Court Used Contempt of Court to Send People to Jail for Years w/Keri Williams

The Everyday Cruelty in Westminster Municipal Court w/Alison Gordon

The Impact of and the Resistance to Mass Deportation Policies w/Hans Meyer and Holly Lucas

How Virginia Prison Officials Lied About Red Onion Prisoner Lighting Themselves on Fire w/Elizabeth Weill-Greenberg

Carceral Apartheid: How Lies and White Supremacists Run Our Prisons w/Brittany Friedman

How a Petty Theft Could get you 180 Days in Jail in Rifle Municipal Court w/Scott Troxell

1/10/25

Save the date! The 2025 ABA Public Defense Summit will be held at Northwestern University School of Law in Chicago on April 4 and 5. This will be our first hybrid summit, with both in-person and live virtual attendance options. Registration will open in the New Year, but in the meantime, please sign up to receive an update when registration becomes available. Full course details will be announced in the coming week.

Welcome to 2025! This newsletter goes all the way back to December 19, so let’s get into it.

National:

Biden gives life in prison to 37 of 40 federal death row inmates before Trump can resume executions

Arkansas:

Report on Arkansas' public defender system finds understaffing, overwork

California:

Supervisors approve new office space for Public Defender’s Office over concerns about cost, park proximity (Lake County)

Florida:

Public defender’s motion to remove judge over texts with Miami-Dade State Attorney denied

Idaho:

ACLU files emergency motion against new public defense system

‘Headed for a disaster:’ ACLU asks Idaho Supreme Court to order public defense system reform

Idaho governor recommends $88 million for State Public Defender FY 2026 budget

Kootenai County cases stall as public defender shortage takes hold

Iowa:

State suspends Washington-based attorney’s license, Justices use case to highlight severe shortage of juvenile public defenders

Maine:

Judge finds Maine public defender program isn’t meeting constitutional obligations

The list of Maine parents waiting for a lawyer grew by 700 percent in 2024 — and it may not account for the whole problem

Experts talk indigent defense in January ‘radio hour’

Missouri:

Lawmakers calling for David Spears termination from public defender’s office

New York:

New Joint Bar Task Force To Tackle Indigent Defense In NYC

North Carolina:

Roy Cooper’s commutations should signal the death penalty’s end in North Carolina

Ohio:

Commissioners approve pact with new group of public defenders (Columbiana)

Pennsylvania:

PA Commission on Crime and Delinquency Delivers More Than $600 Million in Grant Funding Under Shapiro-Davis Administration

Kelly Jurs, veteran Chester County public defender, announces run for judge

McKean County Salary Board approves indigent defense grant payments amid controversy over bonuses and pay disparities

McKean County's bonus controversy, DA criticizes bonuses and pay disparities amid tax hikes

Luzerne County Public Defender’s Office leadership history

Tennessee:

Tennessee revises lethal injection policy nearly three years after last execution was halted

Texas:

High Plains Regional Public Defender's Office to set up at Hale County Courthouse

Washington:

Okanogan County will bring public defenders in-house

West Virginia:

West Virginia Public Defender Services claims lawyer shortage is a statewide problem

Wyoming:

The ‘ticking time bomb’ facing Wyoming’s public defenders and their clients

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How People Are Denied the Right to Counsel in Grand Junction Municipal Court w/Tristan Gorman and Rebecca Wallace

The Policies Making Colorado More "Tough on Crime" w/Tristan Gorman and Rebecca Wallace

BONUS: Discussion/Debate w/a Former Cop about The Killing of Roger Fortson, The Execution of Marcellus Williams and The Citation of a Homeless Pregnant Woman in KY

How Marsy's Law is Undermining the Criminal Legal System w/Ráchael Powers

How to Create More Opportunities to Fight the Government's Case Pre-Trial w/Chesa Boudin and Eric Fish

December 2024

12/18/24

Save the date! The 2025 ABA Public Defense Summit will be held at Northwestern University School of Law in Chicago on April 4 and 5. This will be our first hybrid summit, with both in-person and live virtual attendance options. Registration will open in the New Year, but in the meantime, please sign up to receive an update when registration becomes available. Look for more details in the coming weeks!

This will be the last public defense newsletter of 2024. Happy holidays everyone! See you in the new year.

Colorado:

Denver's Next District Attorney Hasn't Been Sworn in Yet, but He Wants a Raise

Georgia:

Years Pass in a County Jail, Asking for Public Defenders Who Never Answer

Illinois:

‘Legal Giant’ mourned and remembered by his peers (Peoria)

3 Central IL counties get grants for public safety improvements, Budzinski announces

Indiana:

Kosciusko County Council Approves Public Defender’s Office

Steuben eyes full-time public defender office

Iowa:

Indigent Services Crisis Noted In Iowa Discipline Case

Maryland:

Maryland Equitable Justice Commission Proposes 18 Reforms to Address Racial Disparities, Highlighting That Black Residents Make Up 30% of the Population but 71% of Those Incarcerated

Michigan:

Bill would require publicly funded defense attorneys for indigent juveniles

Sen. Sue Shink Commends the Senate Passage of House Bill 4630, Expanding Michigan Indigent Defense Commission to Include Juvenile Defendants

How Michigan Stopped Saddling Children with Millions in Court Debt

Mississippi:

Supes hear plea for an increase to public defender compensation (Winston County)

Montana:

As Community Services Collapse, Experts Say the Mentally Ill are Being Left Behind Bars

New York:

Expanding student debt forgiveness program aims to stop the bleeding in public defense, district attorney’s office

Monroe County public defenders fighting for a new contract, citing pay and caseload

Chenango County Public Defender's Office Awarded NY Grant To Improve And Reduce Caseloads

Ohio:

Allen, Hardin, Putnam counties could share public defenders office

Oregon:

Editorial: Gov. Kotek on Oregon's public defender problem

The Number of Criminal Defendants Without an Attorney Is Still Growing

Pennsylvania:

Juniata officials approve assistant public defender

Washington:

WA court weighs new standards for public defenders

VIDEO: Public defense in Washington bogged down by caseloads and limited staff

Cost of public defense could rise on Palouse

Okanogan County considers bringing public defenders in-house

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How to Create More Opportunities to Fight the Government's Case Pre-Trial w/Chesa Boudin and Eric Fish

How the Supreme Court has Injected Chaos and Confusion into the Second Amendment w/Jacob Charles

How the Junk Science Shaken Baby Syndrome Infected the Criminal Legal System w/Dr. Julie Mack and Randy Papetti

12/11/24

Save the date! The 2025 ABA Public Defense Summit will be held at Northwestern University School of Law in Chicago on April 4 and 5. This will be our first hybrid summit, with both in-person and live virtual attendance options. Registration will open in the New Year, but in the meantime, please sign up to receive an update when registration becomes available. Look for more details in the coming weeks!

It’s a light week for news, but let’s get into it.

California:

Nathan Hochman takes office as new L.A. District Attorney

Public Defenders seek third-year grant for youth advocacy (Solano County)

Florida:

Florida prosecutor seeks to clear records of people charged with buying police-made crack in 1980s

Idaho:

Supreme Court confirms new public defense office must take over costs of transcripts

Indiana:

Indiana Supreme Court justices explain why execution will go forward

Maine:

Attorneys talk challenges, next steps at indigent defense symposium

Nevada:

Deadline to File for Board of Indigent Defense Extended to December 16

New York:

Ethics Opinion 1277: Crowdfunding on behalf of indigent clients

DAs and attorneys call on gov to expand atty loan forgiveness program

NYC Council and Public Advocate File Joint Lawsuit in State Court to Invalidate Mayor’s Emergency Orders Declaring Passage of Law a State of Emergency to Suspend Ban on Solitary Confinement

Oregon:

Grand jury 'appalled' to find Multnomah County is only now looking into replacing its deteriorating jails

South Dakota:

An exciting turning point for the defense of people who can’t afford lawyers

Wisconsin:

Wisconsin public defender budget request includes proposals to cut down criminal charges

Of Interest:

Kash Patel: how Trump’s FBI pick went from public defender to provocateur

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

Why Are Prisoners at Virginia's Red Onion Prison Severely Burning Themselves? w/Phil Wilayto

How the Fear of Too Much Justice Keeps Our Legal System Cruel w/Stephen Bright

The Problems and Promise of Public Defense in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania w/Rob Perkins and Dan Eichinger

How the Junk Science Shaken Baby Syndrome Infected the Criminal Legal System w/Dr. Julie Mack and Randy Papetti

12/4/24

Save the date! The 2025 ABA Public Defense Summit will be held at Northwestern University School of Law in Chicago on April 4 and 5. This will be our first hybrid summit, with both in-person and live virtual attendance options. Registration will open in the New Year, but in the meantime, please sign up to receive an update when registration becomes available. Look for more details in the coming weeks!

This issue of the news covers the last two weeks due to the Thanksgiving holiday.

Arizona:

Gov. Hobbs must share exactly how Arizona plans to execute people | Opinion

California:

Solano Public Defenders seek third-year grant for youth advocacy

Colorado:

Former Colorado public defender alleges he was fired for raising concerns about representing too many clients

Florida:

Hillsborough Public Defender Julianne Holt leaves legacy of service

Maine:

Lawyers for Maine, ACLU file dueling motions to end public defense lawsuit

Maryland:

Fire kills ‘very sweet’ former public defender, damages 8 buildings in Greektown

Michigan:

Defense attorneys frustrated about billing issues, missing payments with Wayne County's IDSD

Wayne County's counsel defends operations of new criminal justice complex

Muskegon County adds 10 staff members to public defenders team

Nevada:

OPINION: Nevadans should demand answers on public defense firing

New Jersey:

Feds Accuse Trenton Police of Pattern of Unconstitutional Brutality and Stops

New York:

County lawmakers to be briefed in private on leave for public defenders

North Carolina:

Attorneys unanimously reappointed to indigent defense roles

Fewer North Carolina attorneys signing up to be public defenders

VIDEO: Legal analysis: Meck County public defender demand

Washington:

The Washington Supreme Court could decide whether public defender caseloads need a dramatic change

Eastern WA Leaders: Public defender caseload plan brings high costs, but no state funding

Wisconsin:

Former public defender accused of abusing his office, paying for sex with client, prosecutors say

Of Interest:

Law students are more diverse, face more debt than 20 years ago, new study says

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

Why Are Prisoner's at Virginia's Red Onion Prison Lighting Themselves on Fire? w/Phil Willayto

Why it's Nearly Impossible to Hold the Government Accountable for Violating your Rights w/Joanna Schwartz

How Prosecutors Might get Rewarded for Messing Up the Harvey Weinstein Case w/Amanda Jack

One Step Forward and Two Steps Back Mississippi Public Defense w/Andre de Gruy

How A.I. Can Help Public Defenders Challenge Police and Prosecutors Part 2 w/Prabhas Pokharel

October 2024

10/23/24

There’s a bit of news from all over the country this week.

National:

Bureau of Justice Statistics: Survey of Public Defenders (SPD) Pilot Report

California:

Audit suggests group homes for California’s sexually violent predators while awaiting long-term placement

D.A. Gascón says two people spent 17 years in prison for a crime they didn’t commit. Now he’s trying to free them

Florida:

Parkland shooting judge criticizes shooter's attorneys during talk to law students

Idaho:

Concerns raised about Idaho’s new public defense system. Several attorneys have left

Idaho's public defense system making big shift

Iowa:

Citing lack of judicial response, State Public Defender asks Iowa Supreme Court to step in

Louisiana:

Louisiana’s newly configured public defender board rejects Landry administration pay plan

Public defenders say new criminal justice laws will further stress office

Massachusetts:

Worcester defense lawyer Stuart Hurowitz nominated for District Court judgeship

For the first time, a public defender is poised to serve on the Mass. Governor's Council

Michigan:

Public defender alleges harassment, discrimination at Plymouth's 35th District Court

St Joseph County commission approves public defenders

Nevada:

Concerns raised after head of state’s indigent defense efforts fired by governor’s office

Oregon:

ACLU Demands Firing of State Public Defense Agency’s Top Lawyer

Pennsylvania:

Lawmakers, public defenders, experts host hearing on state of public defense in PA

South Dakota:

Indigent Legal Services panel preps for launch

Indigent Legal Services Commission Starts To Put Together How New Office Might Function

Texas:

Panhandle Area Public Defender Office celebrates new attorneys

Democratic, Republican candidates vie for seats in Texas Court of Criminal Appeals

Washington:

Jefferson County letter addresses funding obligation

Jefferson commissioners to discuss defense caseloads

Of Interest:

Slate: We Thought the Supreme Court’s Death Penalty Cases Couldn’t Get Worse. We Thought Wrong.

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

The Problems and Potential for Utah's Patchwork Youth Defense System w/Pam Vickrey

The Horrible Direction Louisiana Public Defense is Headed Under its New Leadership w/Derwyn Bunton

How Louisiana's Governor is Reviving the "Super Predator" Myth to Police, Prosecute and Jail Young People w/Hannah Van De Car

10/16/24

This issue of the news covers the last 3 weeks. If you believe any important public defense news items were missed during this extended break, please contact [email protected] so they can be included in next week’s issue.

National:

The Crisis of America’s Public Defenders

Alabama:

Mobile County Public Defenders Office making strides

California:

Opinion: California’s Prop. 36 won’t address retail theft, drug addiction or homelessness

California one of 3 states with no general oversight of public defenders

Your guide to the L.A. County district attorney’s race: Gascón vs. Hochman

Idaho:

Idaho's public defense system making big shift

Idaho State Bar issues ethics opinion on attorneys dropping cases amid public defense change

Concerns raised about Idaho’s new public defense system after exodus in public defenders

New state public defender fills most vacant positions

Illinois:

Lake County announces new public defender

Indiana:

Indiana Public Defender Council warns lawmakers of growing AI-driven false arrest concerns

Maine:

Trial over Maine’s indigent defense crisis set to begin in December

Nevada:

Public defenders tell county proposed homeless ‘camping’ ban ‘is not the solution’

New Hampshire:

VIDEO: Heavy workloads straining public defenders in New Hampshire

New Mexico:

State’s Public Defender Commission Elects New Chair

New York:

Public Defender Speaks To Rotary Club

Ohio:

America’s Public Defender Crisis: How the System Fails the Most Vulnerable

Oregon:

After reforms, Oregon still struggles with shortage of public defenders

Pennsylvania:

Historic Move: Montgomery County Adds 15 Public Defenders Following Statewide Understaffing Reports

Public defender alleging retaliation in lawsuit filed this week

South Dakota:

Addressing South Dakota's public defense gaps

SD Court Leaders Say Reforms To Public Defense Will Take Years, Patience And Engagement

New Indigent Legal Defense program gets high marks despite challenges

Public defense challenges highlighted as commission begins work

Lincoln County to explore option of creating public defender's office

Tennessee:

Nashville District Attorney Funk secretly recorded defense attorneys, state audit finds

Texas:

The Harris County Public Defender’s Office is expanding. But is it growing fast enough?

Travis County passes budget with a focus on justice reform

Public defender's office sets lofty goals for Crossroads community

Utah:

Utah County Commissioners say public defender office mismanaged following 2News probe

Washington:

Proposal aims to cut Washington public defender caseloads, critics say it's too costly

WA Supreme Court is told cutting public defender caseloads could incite ‘vigilante’ justice

State Prosecutors Warn WA Supreme Court About New Public Defense Standards

Washington farm bookkeeper charged with stealing $500k may go free after not getting lawyer in time

Whitman County faces $1 million for public defense

Ex-Franklin leader returns to Tri-Cities. This time to help struggling Benton Co. program (opens as PDF)

Of Interest:

A Public Defender’s Radical Approach to Representing the January 6th Rioters

Staying Zealous: Why I chose to return to public defense after it nearly killed me

As Harris makes case for presidency, her record as prosecutor draws fresh scrutiny

The State of Civil Gideon 60 Years On

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

Why did the Stanislaus County Public Defender Say they Were Ready to Refuse Taking New Cases w/Jennifer Jennison

How Philly Public Defenders Uncovered Systemic Abuses in the Philly Police Department w/Paula Sen and Michael Mellon

The Restorative Justice Program Trying to Heal the Wounds of a Wrongful Conviction w/Jennifer Thompson and Jamie Lau

How Alabama's Fines and Fees Fail Criminal Defendants, Victims, and the Entire State w/Leah Nelson and Judge Stephen Wallace

How the Civil Legal System Makes it Difficult to Hold Larry Nassar, the Catholic Church, and Other Powerful Organizations Accountable w/Parker Stinar

The Courts Giving Young People the Specialized Resources they Need to Succeed w/Paul Bowen and Jacqueline van Wormer

How California Law Enforcement Agencies are Keeping Police Misconduct Hidden w/Katey Rusch

September 2024

9/25/24

The news was off last week, so this is a double issue. Please note that the news will be on a break for the next two weeks while our news team is on vacation.
Look for a lot of news items this week about updated public defense workload standards in Washington State, as well as a multi-part investigation into court delays in Reno, Nevada and news about South Dakota’s first ever chief public defender.

California:

Gascón vs. Hochman: Very different takes on what LA's district attorney should do

$100 a day for jury duty: Alameda County rate jumps from $15

San Francisco public defender urges no drug charges for trafficking victims

Georgia:

Glynn Co. stops payroll services to District Attorney's office following months of financial issues

Idaho:

Public defense changeover raises concerns for some

Idaho's public defense system making big shift

Illinois:

New Lake County public defender named; ‘He has and always will ensure his client’s rights are protected’

‘People who should be held are being held’: Pretrial Fairness Act marks first year this week

Michigan:

Kent County hires public defender for new office

Is justice actually blind? We’ll see (Kalamazoo)

Mississippi:

Marshall Project: Mississippi Court Candidates Tell You Why They Should Be Elected

Missouri:

Missouri executes Marcellus Williams despite pleas from prosecutor and victim’s family

Nevada:

JUSTICE DELAYED Part 1: Washoe County courts are clogged with cases. Prosecutors and public defenders dispute why it’s happening

JUSTICE DELAYED Part 2: More Cases are Going to Trial

JUSTICE DELAYED Part 3: Overworked and understaffed

JUSTICE DELAYED Part 4: Jail called out for causing delays

JUSTICE DELAYED Part 5: County approves some new positions

Pennsylvania:

ACLU: What Pennsylvania’s failure to fund public defenders means across the commonwealth

Pennsylvania OKs $80M for crime data reporting, victim services

AG candidate Eugene DePasquale says leadership is his strength: ‘You’re not just electing a robot’

South Dakota:

Q&A: Meet South Dakota’s first state public defender

Indigent Defense Board names first chief defender

Millions allocated to counties to fund public defense efforts

State sends counties $3 million for indigent defense, covering 12% of expenses

Study finds SD indigent criminal defense weak

Brown County to get nearly $100K to help with indigent-defense legal services (partial paywall)

Texas:

Williamson County judge appointed to Texas indigent defense board

Washington:

Press Release: Washington Supreme Court Sets Public Hearing Sept. 25 on Proposed Changes to Indigent Defense

Washington Supreme Court schedules public hearing on indigent defense standards

Plan to cut WA public defender caseloads would have profound consequences

Lewis County raises concern over cost of new public defender requirements

King County Department of Public Defense Director Resigns Abruptly

A decision from the state Supreme Court could turn justice system into legal chaos

Of Interest:

Debut novel of former Orleans public defender follows the 'hopeless state' of the court system

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How NACDL is Helping Public and Private Defenders Fight Back Against New Oppressive Policies w/Lisa Wayne

The Highest Law in the Land: How the Unchecked Power of Sheriffs Threatens Democracy w/Jessica Pishko

The Problems with Public Defense in Nueces County Texas w/Jessica Brand and Adrienne Johnson

The Systemic Corruption and Coverups at the Denver Sheriff Department w/Brittany Iriart and Andy McNulty

Venezuelan Gangs Haven't Taken Over Aurora, But What is Happening? w/Chase Woodruff

9/11/24

With Labor Day behind us and summer vacation season officially over, the number of public defense news articles is on the rise. Among other items, look for stories this week about the ongoing public defender strike in Sacramento.

Of Interest:

How to Approach the Crisis of Mass Incarceration

Sergio de la Pava, Agent of Change

Alaska:

Alaska Judge’s Sex Scandal Brings Scrutiny to US Attorney Tucker

Arkansas:

Benton County Public Defenders attending some bond hearings after federal judge’s ruling (PARTIAL PAYWALL)

California:

Sacramento County public attorneys heading into third week of mass strike

Sacramento County criminal justice attorneys union pauses strike until Tuesday

Striking attorneys agree to ‘cease-fire’ with Sacramento County, go back to work until Tuesday

Alternate Public Defender tapped as new Superior Court commissioner (Solano County)

How George Gascón went from cop to one of the most progressive DAs in the country

Colorado:

Aurora City Council votes to shift domestic violence cases to county courts

D.C.:

Press Release: Norton Introduces Bill to Allow D.C. Courts and D.C. Public Defender Service to Offer Buyouts to Employees

Florida:

Public Defender Julianne Holt steps down: Reflecting on 30 years of legal and legislative impact

Georgia:

Press Release: Director Rachel Rossi Delivers Keynote Remarks at the Georgia Legal Services Program Pro Bono Conference

Massachusetts:

The Public Defender Who Just Won Power Over Confirming Massachusetts Judges

Michigan:

Local attorney appointed director of new Kent County Public Defender’s Office (PARTIAL PAYWALL)

Nevada:

Committee to sponsor ‘second look’ bill that allows for reduction of lengthy prison sentences

New York:

Attorney sues Oswego County for discrimination over public defender job

North Carolina:

Hundreds of NC defense attorneys waited months for pay in 2016. It could happen again.

Pennsylvania:

Grant creates ‘more even playing field’ in criminal justice system (Miffin County)

Texas:

Governor Abbott Appoints Gravell and Miskel to Texas Indigent Defense Commission Board

VIDEO: Indigent Defense Commission Governing Board

Public Safety Commission Begins Process to Name New DPS Director

Public defender successful in reducing costs across five counties (Far West)

Outgoing Harris County Democratic District Attorney Addresses Tea Party on Crime, Public Corruption

Does 'Heath' Have Teeth? The New Era of Criminal Discovery Rights in Texas (PAYWALL)

Washington:

State Sen. Mike Padden: Washington needs more public defenders and prosecutors, along with police

In Memoriam:

Bob Mann, lawyer who took on some of RI's most notorious cases, has died

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

Between 46%-99% of Colorado Public Defenders are Overworked. Why is the State Waiting Two Years for Workload Standards w/James Hardy and Kayleigh TenBarge

How the Junk Science "Excited Delirium" Shields Cops From Accountability w/Rachel Kincaid

9/4/24

As is usually the case during holidays, this was a light week for public defense news.

Of Interest:

Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson is hitting the road to promote her new memoir, ‘Lovely One’

California:

Sacramento Public Defenders, Prosecutors Strike Continues

What should justice look like? Your vote for LA County DA is a choice between two visions

Indiana:

Commission Brainstorms Plan To Save Indiana's Legal Future

Iowa:

New Criminal Defense Clinic director to focus on post-conviction and clemency

Louisiana:

New Orleans district attorney’s progressive policies face blowback from Louisiana’s conservative Legislature

Maine:

In York County, two-thirds of defendants waiting for lawyers face domestic violence charges

Maine public defenders ask for big pay raise

Massachusetts:

Progressive Vs. Moderate: Suffolk County Clerk Race Heats Up In Democratic Primary‌

Michigan:

Hillsdale Commissioners narrowly approve public defender administrator contract

Kent County hires public defender for new office

Press Release: Governor Whitmer Makes Appointments to Boards and Commissions

Oregon:

Oregon law rolling back drug decriminalization takes effect, making possession a crime again

Willamette Criminal Defense Clinic launches this fall

South Dakota:

Brown County moves toward creating public defender’s office

Texas:

Smith County commissioners approve 2025 budget with raises for indigent defense attorneys, additions to jail

Washington:

Olympia needs to double its budget for criminal defense attorneys each year until 2027

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How Oklahoma is Giving a Second Chance to Criminalized Domestic Violence Survivors w/Alexandra Bailey

What Was Happening in Grants Pass, Oregon Before the Supreme Court OK'd Criminalizing Homelessness w/Jeremiah Hayden

How a Person Can Get Evicted for being the Victim of a Crime too Many Times w/Alex Kornya

The Challenges of Providing Holistic Defense in Rural North Carolina w/Beth Stang

August 2024

8/28/24

Look for news this week about Maine’s growing public defender system and a public defender strike in Sacramento, California.

Arkansas:

Gov. Sanders approves funds to pay salaries for Benton County public defenders

Federal judge rules people in Benton County should be appointed public defenders at bond hearings

California:

Prosecutors and public defenders strike for higher pay in this California county (Sacramento)

Stanford Law clinic stands up for indigent defense

Colorado:

Youth facing municipal charges in Denver get public defenders, something other municipalities across Colorado want

Opinion: Dems engorge budget of state public defender (good for a laugh -ed)

Florida:

Bradshaw And Gauger Advance In Sheriff’s Race; Eisinger To Serve As Next Public Defender

Palm Beach state attorney had no business endorsing public defender | Opinion

Idaho:

Idaho is overhauling its public defense system, but some argue it won’t fix issues providing attorneys

Opinion: Public defense

Kansas:

The weight of the wait 30 years after Kansas death penalty law

Why Kevin Cook is stepping aside as Topeka Municipal Court public defender

Maine:

‘No easy fix’ to Maine’s indigent defense crisis, director tells lawmakers

Maine's public defense commission seeks additional $64 million to fund new offices, boost lawyer pay

Lewiston attorney tapped to head up local indigent defense office

Maine slowly staffing up growing network of public defenders offices

Head of Maine Public Defenders addresses concerns at Government Oversight Committee

Michigan:

MSU College of Law opens Public Defender Clinic

New Mexico:

Courts launch novel program for mentally ill defendants

New York:

Chenango County Public Defender To Receive $186,000 Grant For Discovery Aid

Oregon:

Column: Solving Oregon’s public defender problem will involve more than money

Pennsylvania:

Historic Move: Montgomery County Adds 15 Public Defenders Following Statewide Understaffing Reports

Texas:

Former Fort Bend County public defender files lawsuit over alleged retaliatory termination

Library to host discussion of possibility of a Public Defender Office in county

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How the Los Angeles Public Defender Is Bringing Court to their Clients w/Ricardo Garcia and Marcus Huntley

How Oklahoma is Giving a Second Chance to Criminalized Domestic Violence Survivors w/Alexandra Bailey

8/21/24

Look for news this week about ongoing public defense reforms in Idaho, Maine, and Washington.

National:

Readout of the Justice Department Quarterly Convening with National Public Defense Organizations

Of Interest:

SMU Deason Center’s tireless warrior holds feet to the fire when it comes to public defense

What 9 cases from Kamala Harris’ past say about her record as a California prosecutor

Robert Perkins and Wesley Caines: Holistic defense can change lives

California:

Calls Mount For OC’s District Attorney To Figure Out Where $13 Million in COVID Funds Went

Florida:

Melissa Vickers triumphs in Orange-Osceola County public defender race

Lisa McLean wins in Hillsborough public defender race

Georgia:

Georgia district attorney candidate vows to end Young Thug trial if elected

Idaho:

Changes coming to public defense in Idaho

Idaho's public defense system making big shift

The defense rests: Kootenai attorneys warn of looming crisis

Indiana:

Judges ask to increase public defender pay

Maine:

Court says ACLU can name state of Maine in indigent defense lawsuit

Bangor’s new public defender office is struggling to hire lawyers

Public defender’s offices are opening across Maine. The next step: staffing them.

Massachusetts:

Impacted by clearing, public defender sees increase in charges against homeless

North Carolina:

IDS launching online payment system for appointed counsel

Oregon:

Report Finds Top Lawyer at State Public Defense Agency Retaliated Against Two Female Lawyers

Pennsylvania:

Montco will seek to hire 15 new public defenders to address a longstanding staffing shortage

‘Game-changer’: Montgomery County pledges to significantly expand public defender’s office

Texas:

Opinion: Ken Paxton got pretrial diversion. Shouldn’t more Texans get it too?

Washington:

Would overhaul of WA’s public defense lead to better outcomes or ‘vigilante land’?

Washington Bar Changes to Help Public Defenders, Questions Remain on Funding

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

The Problems with Public Defense in Guam w/Aditi Goel

With a Conservative Supreme Court, Do State Courts Offer the Best Path for a Better Criminal Legal System? w/Kathrina (Kasia) Szymborski Wolfkot

8/14/24

There’s a bit of news from all over this week, including several stories about public defender elections in Florida.

National:

Biden Public Defenders Turned Judges Begin to Make Mark on Bench

Alabama:

Well-known lawyer, former Alabama state senator cannot serve as public defender in 2 counties, judge rules

Alaska:

Alaska Prosecutor Accused of Exploiting Judge Ties for Recusal

Arkansas:

Smith County addresses personnel, approves road projects

Colorado:

Audit: Colorado public defender's office has high workloads, must study staffing

Florida:

Longtime Public Defender Endorses Candidate to Replace Him, Continue Legacy (Orlando)

10th Circuit Public Defender position up for election

In race for Public Defender, Republican candidates spar over who's more conservative (Lakeland)

Op-ed: Don’t fall for lies in Palm Beach public defender’s race

Leon County's new restorative justice agency aims to bring better outcomes for victims and offenders

Illinois:

Estimated cost for the proposed Tazewell County Justice Center Annex: $44 million

Indiana:

Judges ask to increase public defender pay (Bartholomew County)

Louisiana:

State Supreme Court issues “bench book” to guide sentencing decisions

Maine:

Utility company’s proposal to rat out hidden marijuana operations to police raises privacy concerns

Mississippi:

Sweltering Heat Endangers Incarcerated in Mississippi Prison

North Carolina:

IDS Launching New Payment System for Appointed Counsel in eCourts Counties

Alamance Commissioners hear court expansion ideas; where current county offices could be moved

Oregon:

Editorial: Oregon continues unacceptable failure to provide public defenders

Editorial: Solving public defender problem involves more than money

Tennessee:

Lee Davis Has Seen Positive Changes In The Administration Of Justice, He Tells Civitans

Texas:

At Smith County budget workshop, judges push for indigent defense funding

$120,000 salary for contract attorneys back on table in Smith County

Washington:

Longtime Tri-Cities defense leader leaving. WA courts can't handle what's coming, he says

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How Police Academies Foster a Culture of Police Violence w/Samantha Simon

What Changes are Coming to Fix Maine's Public Defense Crisis? w/Jim Billings

8/7/24

The news was off last week due to the ABA Annual Meeting, so this issue covers two weeks.

Of Interest:

Civil rights icon receives ABA’s highest honor

Arresting Homeless People Is the ‘Most Expensive and Least Effective’ Solution

'I do miss him': Trans Public Defender Sofia Nelson mourns the JD Vance they knew at Yale

District of Columbia:

Judge Milton Lee named new chief of D.C. Superior Court

Florida:

Orange-Osceola public defender candidates seek to make history

Editorial: Choose Daniel Eisinger for Palm Beach County Public Defender

Kentucky:

Can artificial intelligence help in KY legal defense? Yes, public defenders say

Maine:

Maine's public defense commission adds some flexibility to lawyer qualification standards

The Maine Supreme Court asked large law firms for help. They didn’t.

Rooks: Maine public defender requirements need immediate fix

Third ‘radio hour’ covers public defense, aging care facilities

Michigan:

Press Release: Gov. Whitmer Makes Appointments to the Bench

Kent County announces new office of the Public Defender

New York:

Cornell Law’s Criminal Appellate Defense Clinic Provides Students With Unique Opportunity

A former public defender’s lessons for law students

North Carolina:

Checking in on the Pender County's public defense office, one year after opening

Oklahoma:

Brigitte Biffle takes on heavy role of chief public defender

Oregon:

Oregon public defense commission drafts ‘crisis plan’ to cut number of defendants without lawyers

Oregon Public Defense Commission details multi-pronged efforts to stem public defender crisis

GUEST COLUMN: It takes more than money to solve Oregon's public defender crisis

Pennsylvania:

Philly public defenders voted against getting $6,000 raises if it meant weakening job protections

Lycoming County commissioners: New coroner building, ADA ramp, and public defender grants

South Carolina:

The best offense is a good defense

Texas:

Gregg County public defenders to receive pay bump

Virginia:

Virginia Indigent Defense Commission, Richmond

Wyoming:

Governor Announces Appointment Of Interim State Public Defender

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

How the Lack of Independence Weakens Federal Public Defense w/Melody Brannon

How the Threat of a Strike got Minnesota's Public Defenders a 25% Raise w/Bob Kolstad and Veronica Surges

The Problems with Public Defense in Florida and Georgia w/Radley Balko

How the Good Faith Exception is Eroding Our Right to Privacy w/Matthew Tokson

July 2024

7/25/24

Join the ABA Standing Committee on Legal Aid and Indigent Defense at this year’s ABA Annual Meeting in Chicago for two events celebrating the 50th anniversary of the Legal Services Corporation! On August 1, see the Chicago Cubs play the St. Louis Cardinals at Wrigley Field in an LSC and ABA sponsored event. Then, on August 3 at 5:00 pm, there will be a FREE reception at the downtown Hyatt Regency. Register at the links provided.

Of Interest:

ABA Medal recipient puts democratic principles and indigent defense at center of long career

Here’s what would be happening to Donald Trump right now if he were poor

National:

Opinion: Funding Public Defense Furthers Community Safety

How Project 2025 Plans for Trump to Have Unprecedented Power Over the Justice Department

Alaska:

Federal prosecutors: Resigned Alaska federal judge had conflict of interest in 23 criminal cases

Arkansas:

Revolving bail fund project aims to help poor make bond in Northwest Arkansas

California:

Public Defender’s Office Takes Action Following Ransomware Attack on LA superior Court Systems

Ex-employee says he didn’t mean to send ‘panties’ email to district attorney. He sues

California sent a mentally ill man to a state hospital. Then it charged him $760,000

Colorado:

Editorial: For the sake of victims, move Aurora’s domestic violence courts away from city’s political quagmire

Florida:

Judge: Miami-Dade public defenders did not witness tamper, can remain on murder case

Questionnaire: Daniel Eisinger, candidate for Palm Beach County Public Defender

Tensions mark Hillsborough public defender campaigns

Who should replace longtime Hillsborough Public Defender Julianne Holt? We have an answer.

Georgia:

National bail fund returns to Georgia after judge says limits were arbitrary

Idaho:

Jordan Crane appointed as public defender for Seventh Judicial District

Indiana:

Black people overrepresented in arrests for HIV-related donation crimes in Indiana

Maine:

Defense attorneys say indigent work remains a heavy lift, despite pay increase

Maryland:

State sees nearly $150 million in budget cuts

Michigan:

New Office of the Public Defender opens in Kent Co., applications now open

Oklahoma:

Judge declares Oklahoma law allows victims to be present at all hearings

Pennsylvania:

Pa.’s lack of support for public defenders is unconstitutional. So we’re suing.

Pennsylvanians deserve a better indigent defense system

Washington:

Indigent defense caseloads may decrease

Washington Supreme Court seeks input on changes to public defense standards

WA Supreme Court considers cutting public defender caseloads

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

If Another Person Confesses to a Crime, Why Can't Jurors Hear that Evidence? w/Sharon Turlington

What Actually Happened to Minnesota's Legal and Public Defender System After the Murder of George Floyd w/Bill Ward

7/17/24

Join the ABA Standing Committee on Legal Aid and Indigent Defense at this year’s ABA Annual Meeting in Chicago for two events celebrating the 50th anniversary of the Legal Services Corporation! On August 1, see the Chicago Cubs play the St. Louis Cardinals at Wrigley Field in an LSC and ABA sponsored event. Then, on August 3 at 5:00 pm, there will be a FREE reception at the downtown Hyatt Regency. Register at the links provided.

There is not a lot of news this week, but be sure to see that the Washington Supreme Court is seeking public comment on proposed public defense standards.

Arizona:

Tucson attorney Bob Hirsh to lead Pima County public defenders

Florida:

Two Attorneys Aim To Become County’s Next Public Defender (Palm Beach)

Frankel Secures Key Endorsements in County Public Defender Race

Dubbed ‘toxic,’ top candidate for Orange-Osceola public defender was forced to quit the office she wants to lead

Illinois:

Lake County public defender retires after 37 years of service

Champaign County jail bookings remain stable while public defender workload triples to keep clients out of jail under SAFE-T Act

A trial that lasted 45 minutes convicted an innocent boy

Kentucky:

Old team cries foul after former public defender switches sides (Frankfort)

Maryland:

Defense attorneys call attention to ‘infuriating’ trend by Baltimore prosecutors to drop and recharge cases

Michigan:

New state funding not enough to solve shortage of prosecutors, counties say

Pennsylvania:

$47.6 Billion PA State Budget Signed by Governor Shapiro

Washington:

Proposed Changes to Washington Supreme Court Public Defense Standards Open for Public Comment

International:

Israel's Public Defender: Emergency Legislation During War Seriously Infringes on Rights of Prisoners

In Memoriam:

Abe Krash, one of the attorneys who represented Clarence Earl Gideon and helped usher in the right to public defense, died on July 6 at his home in Maryland. As a junior attorney on the case, Krash was responsible for most of the research and writing. He was 97.

7/10/24

Join the ABA Standing Committee on Legal Aid and Indigent Defense at this year’s ABA Annual Meeting in Chicago for two events celebrating the 50th anniversary of the Legal Services Corporation. On August 1, see the Chicago Cubs play the St. Louis Cardinals at Wrigley Field in an LSC and ABA sponsored event. Then, on August 3 at 5:00 pm, there will be a FREE reception at the downtown Hyatt Regency. Register at the links provided.

Holidays usually make for a slow news week, and this was no exception.

Colorado:

Denver kids and teens will now receive free public defenders in municipal court

Hawaii:

Short-Handed Kona Public Defender’s Office Won’t Accept New Drunken Driving Cases

Indiana:

Koch reappointed to Indiana Public Defender Commission

Maine:

Across Maine, judges are deciding when the lack of an attorney becomes a constitutional violation

Maine's public defender crisis devolves into a blame game

The region’s first public defender starts work (Piscataquis and Penobscot Counties)

Massachusetts:

Public defenders demand 'comprehensive reforms' at state police after Fitchburg ruling

Missouri:

Missouri counties say they lose money housing people headed to state prison

Nevada:

Clark Hill Wins for Public Defender in Nevada State Bar Disciplinary Hearing

New York:

Bronx Defenders union authorizes potential strike

Chairman's Corner: Conflict Defender (Columbia County)

North Carolina:

Dorn takes office as Johnston County’s chief public defender

Oregon:

Editorial: The unjust is sticking in Oregon courts

Pennsylvania:

Fired Public Defender’s Age Discrimination Claim Moves Forward (partial paywall)

Tennessee:

Legal Notes: Indigent defense funding increase takes effect

‘Clear appearance of bias’: Judge booted from defense lawyer’s cases after actions ‘indicative of personal animosity’

Utah:

Utah public defenders are anxious about the Supreme Court’s camping ban decision

Podcasts:

Public Defenseless:

The Rise, Fall, and Disbarment of Florida's Worst Chief Public Defender w/Andrew Pantazi

What Can Save Pennsylvania Public Defense w/Sara Jacobson, Autumn Johnson, Samuel Encarnacion

The ACLU Lawsuit Seeking to Radically Change Pennsylvania Public Defense w/Vic Walczak and Veronica Miller

7/3/24:

Join the ABA Standing Committee on Legal Aid and Indigent Defense at this year’s ABA Annual Meeting in Chicago for two events celebrating the 50th anniversary of the Legal Services Corporation. On August 1, see the Chicago Cubs play the St. Louis Cardinals at Wrigley Field in an LSC and ABA sponsored event. Then, on August 3 at 5:00 pm, there will be a FREE reception at the downtown Hyatt Regency. Register at the links provided.

Due to holidays and other commitments, this newsletter covers the past 3 weeks. Strap in for a lot of headlines. Happy Fourth!

National:

ABA honors 2024 public service award recipients

California:

The criminal justice system in SF is badly broken, and the mayor’s budget doesn’t help

Kern County Bar Association renews contract to oversee Indigent Defense Program

Letter: SF Public Defender Applauds Restoration of State’s Public Defender Pilot Program and Urges Permanent Funding

Colorado:

Aurora lawmakers to discuss plan for ridding municipal court of domestic violence cases

Weld County will not criminally charge forensic scientist over anomalies in DNA casework

Connecticut:

TaShun Bowden-Lewis sues over CT chief public defender firing

Illinois:

Lake County’s chief public defender retires after 37 years in office, breaking history as first female in position

Indiana:

State Sen. Eric Koch was reappointed to Indiana Public Defender Commission

Kentucky:

Jefferson County public defender’s office now part of DPA

Louisiana:

Louisiana’s death penalty spending stays the course, despite public defense shakeup

State public defender board wrestles with how to hire outside legal help in death penalty cases

Maine:

Six months in, Maine’s first public defenders’ office talks strategy

Our View: Reform of Maine’s public defense system is the bottom line

Rooks: Deadly consequences of Maine's failing indigent defense system must be addressed

Opinion: Law students demand solutions to Maine’s Sixth Amendment crisis

Michigan:

Plymouth public defender sues 35th District Court for alleged bias and harassment against lower-income defendants

Northeast Michigan guilty pleas return to normal

Mississippi:

Mississippi wants to allow some votes from jails and prisons. Red tape may stop it.

Nebraska:

Rural NE county attorneys, public defenders confront ‘legal desert’ in hiring new lawyers

Nevada:

Las Vegas judge ordered to attend ethics class after hot tub photo, ‘egregious’ behavior

New Jersey:

Public defender’s office touts new police accountability director

New York:

NY Chief Judge Spotlights Need To Strengthen Public Defense

Republican lawmakers ask judge to remove Erie County’s top public defender

Opinion: A call to action to solve New York’s criminalization of homelessness

Oregon:

Oregon launches new public defender division to stem constitutional crisis

Pennsylvania:

Pennsylvania public defense system is unconstitutional, underfunded by at least $100M, new ACLU suit says

The ACLU says Pennsylvania’s public defenders are so underfunded it violates the law

100,000 Pa. residents left without legal help, ACLU files lawsuit

Following ACLU lawsuit, counties say Pa. should boost indigent defense funding even more

Opinion: Pennsylvanians deserve a better indigent defense system

Public defenders using state money for new positions, equipment

Press Release: Senator Hughes Announces Over $250K for Indigent Defense in Philadelphia and Montgomery Counties

Sen. Collett secures $500,000 for Victims’ Services, Indigent Defense and crime prevention in Montco

New Licensing Regulations Aim to Open Doors for Pennsylvanians with Criminal Records

Tennessee:

Nearly 30 cases taken from Shelby County judge's court due to conflict with public defender

Texas:

His mother got him out of jail but his lawyer got paid? Harris County’s court-appointed lawyer system is broken.

Washington:

Walking in Their Shoes: Life in the public defense machine amid newly recommended caseload standards

Public defender case limits per lawyer may reduce if rules change, worrying cities of budget costs to hire more lawyers

Public defender shortage is a WA crisis that requires local and state action

Island County officials consider bringing public defense in-house

In Memoriam: Doug Wilson

Doug was an accomplished public defender, having served persons in need of a criminal defense lawyer in Colorado since the early 1980s, eventually serving as the state’s chief trial deputy and chief public defender. Doug even came out of retirement to serve as the chief public defender in the embattled Aurora Public Defender’s Office until his second retirement in 2023. He represented many capitally charged clients during his career at a time when the Colorado public defense community was considered at the forefront of successful capital trial strategy, helping to develop methods that are still used by capital defenders to this day. He will be greatly missed.

PODCASTS:

Public Defenseless:

Travis Finck: On the Brink of a Crisis, What can Be Done to Save North Dakota Public Defense?

Grant Miller: The Utah Public Defender Campaigning to Bring Big Changes to the Utah State Legislature

Chesa Boudin: Lessons Learned from San Francisco's Progressive Prosecution Movement

Eric Whitcher: South Dakota's Small First Step to Statewide Public Defense

Scarlett Lewis: After Her Son was Murdered at Sandy Hook, One Mother's Fight to Reduce Violence by Choosing Love

Angela Chang and Brooke Burns: How Ohio Public Defenders Push Back Against the Return of the "Super Predator" Myth

Why did the Bronx Defender's Union Vote to go on Strike? w/Tyler Johnson, Marlene Marte, Katherine Azcona