A few decades ago, there were no page limits for U.S. Supreme Court briefs, and that brought considerable headaches for the clerks who had to read them. Also, the justices rarely, if ever, asked more than 15 questions total during oral arguments. But that changed in 1986, after Antonin Scalia joined the high court.
“When Justice Scalia started asking questions, that caused Justice [John Paul] Stevens to ask questions, and Justice [Thurgood] Marshall to ask more questions,” says Carter Phillips, who was an assistant to the U.S. solicitor general in the U.S. Department of Justice from 1981 to 1984 and has argued 79 cases before the Supreme Court.
Phillips and Michael Dreeben, who worked in the solicitor general’s office for more than 30 years, including 24 as its deputy in charge of the Supreme Court criminal docket, are featured in this month’s Asked and Answered podcast, which is looking at how advocacy has changed in the country’s highest court. It’s part of a special series on how lawyers’ work has changed over the years.
Send ideas for future episodes to ABA Journal Senior Writer Stephanie Francis Ward.