chevron-down Created with Sketch Beta.

ARTICLE

October CRSJ Chair's Column

Lacy L Durham

October CRSJ Chair's Column
Hill Street Studios via Getty Images

Dear ABA Civil Rights and Social Justice Section Family,

As we step into a new bar year, reflecting on the significant events that have shaped our journey and the ongoing challenges that demand our collective action is crucial. This has been a period of deep reflection and pivotal moments in civil rights and social justice. We have experienced so much in such a short period; it is a powerful reminder of the progress we've made and the work that remains.

I challenge you to find your areas of concern and dive into the most pressing issues impacting civil rights and social justice today. I challenge you to answer the call to action. Now is the time to engage, act, and make your voice heard. Here are some ways to stay informed and contribute to meaningful change. 

Hurricanes Helene and Milton: Devastation and Inequity

The recent impact of Hurricanes Helene and Milton have left communities devastated, highlighting severe inequities in disaster response and recovery efforts. How can we ensure marginalized communities receive the needed aid and support?

Natural disasters like Hurricanes Helene and Milton underscore the intersection of civil rights issues, revealing systemic inequities in disaster preparedness, response, and recovery. Vulnerable communities often face disproportionate impacts, exacerbating pre-existing social and economic disparities. It's crucial to stay vigilant for unequal resource distribution, discriminatory practices in relief efforts, and neglect of marginalized populations. Ensuring equitable access to aid, advocating for inclusive policies, and holding authorities accountable for their actions are essential steps in addressing these injustices. By recognizing and responding to these civil rights challenges, we can work towards more resilient and just communities in the face of natural disasters.

Call to Action: Join our upcoming virtual CLE Conference on disaster response and civil rights to explore solutions and advocate for equitable policies. Register now to secure your spot!

Execution of Marcellus Williams: A Call for Justice

The execution of Marcellus Williams raises questions about the death penalty and racial bias in the criminal justice system. How do we confront and rectify these injustices?

The Williams case highlights profound injustices and civil rights violations within the American criminal justice system. Williams, an African American man, was sentenced to death in Missouri for the 1998 murder of Felicia Gayle, a former journalist. Despite the gravity of the charge, his conviction was marred by significant doubts and concerns about racial bias, inadequate legal representation, and the reliability of evidence. Crucially, DNA testing conducted in 2015 on the murder weapon revealed that Williams' DNA was not present, yet the state continued to pursue his execution. This case exemplifies the systemic issues of racial discrimination and the potential for wrongful convictions, raising critical questions about the fairness and integrity of the death penalty.

Marcellus Williams' execution was scheduled despite these unresolved doubts and the clear evidence pointing to his potential innocence. The Missouri Supreme Court and the Governor faced immense pressure from advocates, legal experts, and civil rights organizations to stay his execution and reexamine the case. Williams' situation underscores the urgent need for reforms to ensure that justice is served without prejudice and that the death penalty is not administered where there is significant doubt about guilt. His case is a stark reminder of the broader issues of racial injustice, the need for rigorous legal standards, and the importance of protecting the civil rights of all individuals within the judicial system.

Call to Action: Check out CRSJ's Death Penalty Due Process Review Project, which features legal experts and activists who will examine the implications of the death penalty. CRSJ Special Counsel Melanie E. Bates recently penned an an opinion piece on the recent execution.

Justice Department's Civil Rights Probe: Accountability and Reform

Following the shocking torture of two Black men, the Justice Department has launched a civil rights probe into the sheriff's office. What can be done to ensure accountability and prevent such atrocities?

The horrific case involving the torture of two Black men by a local sheriff's office has ignited outrage and led the Justice Department to initiate a far-reaching civil rights investigation. The two men were subjected to brutal and inhumane treatment while in custody, enduring severe physical abuse, threats, and psychological torment. The abuse they faced included being handcuffed, beaten, and subjected to extreme and unjustifiable force, actions that not only inflicted severe physical injuries but also caused deep emotional and mental anguish.

These actions constitute clear violations of the Eighth Amendment, which protects individuals from cruel and unusual punishment, as well as the Fourteenth Amendment, which guarantees equal protection under the law. The case has highlighted pervasive issues of systemic racism, excessive use of force, and abuse of power within the sheriff's office. Reports indicate that these violations were not isolated incidents, but part of a broader pattern of discriminatory practices and unchecked misconduct within the department.

The Justice Department's civil rights probe seeks to uncover the full scope of these violations, ensuring that those responsible are held accountable. This investigation aims to bring justice to the victims and to implement critical reforms within the sheriff's office to prevent such egregious acts from recurring. The case underscores the urgent need for systemic change in law enforcement practices, emphasizing the importance of transparency, accountability, and the protection of civil rights for all individuals, particularly those from marginalized communities who are disproportionately affected by such abuses.

Call to Action: For more information and ways to address these issues, see the CRSJ Criminal Justice Committee.

2025 Election: Ensuring Fairness and Transparency

As we approach the 2025 election, issues of voter rights, transparency, and fair elections are more crucial than ever. One major concern is the targeting of election officials that has resulted in heightened threats, harassment, and even criminal prosecutions against those dedicated to ensuring fair elections. These actions are driven by disinformation and conspiracy theories, which undermine public trust in the electoral process​. Voter suppression efforts also continue to be a pressing issue, with new laws in several states imposing harsh penalties on election officials for minor mistakes or legitimate efforts to assist voters. These measures disproportionately affect minority communities, exacerbating existing inequalities.

Additionally, there are ongoing challenges related to voter intimidation and the legitimacy of mail-in ballots and absentee voting in several states. These issues underscore the need for vigilance and advocacy to safeguard the democratic process and ensure that every eligible voter can participate without fear of intimidation or discrimination. As the election draws near, it is crucial to stay informed and engaged in efforts to protect voting rights and uphold the integrity of the electoral system. Ask yourself, how can I safeguard our democracy and ensure every vote counts?

Call to Action: Join our Perfecting Democracy training efforts to mobilize attorneys, law students, and advocates in election protection efforts. Check out the resources that include tools for educating the public, litigating pre- and post-election issues, and directly defending election officials who face harassment and legal challenges and tune into the Perfecting Democracy Chair Chat series, featuring on-demand conversations with Damon Hewitt and Terry Ao Minnis. The initiative underscores the critical role of legal professionals in upholding democratic principles and ensuring that every vote counts, emphasizing the importance of civic engagement and legal advocacy in protecting civil rights and social justice. Your participation is vital—sign up to volunteer!

Hispanic Heritage Month: Celebrating Contributions and Advancing Civil Rights

As we celebrate Hispanic Heritage Month from September 15th to October 15th, we honor the rich cultural heritage, history, and contributions of Hispanic and Latino Americans. This month is a time to recognize the vital role that Hispanic communities have played in shaping our nation's history, from their influence in the arts and sciences to their advocacy for civil rights and social justice. Hispanic Heritage Month also serves as a reminder of the ongoing struggle for equality and the importance of addressing issues such as immigration reform, voting rights, and economic disparities. By celebrating Hispanic Heritage Month, we reaffirm our commitment to creating a more inclusive and equitable society for all.

Reflecting on Civil Rights Anniversaries Since September 1st

Since September 1st, we have commemorated several significant civil rights anniversaries highlighting the ongoing fight for justice and equality. On September 4th, we marked the anniversary of the Little Rock Nine's courageous integration of Central High School in 1957, a pivotal moment in the desegregation of American schools. September 15th also reminded us of the tragic bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church in 1963, where four young Black girls lost their lives in a heinous act of racial violence, spurring more significant momentum for the Civil Rights Movement. These anniversaries are not just historical milestones but powerful reminders of the sacrifices made and the work that remains in our quest for true equality. As we reflect on these events, we renew our dedication to upholding the principles of justice and civil rights for all.

The Right to Fair Wages and the Right to Collaborate

The International Longshoremen's Association (ILA) began a strike, impacting East Coast and Gulf Coast ports from Maine to Texas. This action follows the failure of negotiations between the ILA and the United States Maritime Alliance (USMX), which represents ocean carriers and port operators. The core issues include inadequate wage offers from USMX despite these ocean carriers' significant profits. The ILA has expressed that their workers deserve fair compensation for their crucial role in maintaining American commerce, especially in the face of rising living costs due to inflation. ​This strike has significant implications for the economy, as these ports handle a substantial portion of the nation's imports. The ripple effects could disrupt various industries and lead to increased consumer costs due to higher shipping rates. The strike also highlights critical labor rights issues that intersect with civil rights concerns. As workers rally for fair wages, safe working conditions, and better benefits, the strike brings to light the broader struggle for economic justice and the protection of workers' rights. Many of the strikers come from marginalized communities where economic exploitation and workplace discrimination are rampant. These workers often face systemic barriers to equal opportunities and fair treatment. The strike underscores the need for stronger protections against discriminatory practices, wage theft, and unsafe working environments. Additionally, it calls for the recognition of the right to unionize and collectively bargain without fear of retaliation. As the strike progresses, it serves as a powerful reminder that labor rights are inherently tied to civil rights and that achieving true equality requires addressing the economic disparities and injustices faced by workers from all walks of life. 

Ongoing Conflicts: Human Rights at Stake

The ongoing conflict in Gaza continues to escalate, with significant human rights violations reported. How can the international community, especially legal professionals, contribute to peace and justice in the region?

Navigating Conflict with Respect, Decorum, and Cultural Sensitivity

A year later, the conflict in Gaza continues to escalate with significant human rights and civil rights violations reported that deeply affecting the lives of both Palestinians and Israelis alike. The war has led to severe humanitarian crises, with widespread displacement, destruction of homes, and a lack of access to essential services such as healthcare, education, and clean water. These conditions exacerbate existing social and economic inequalities, stripping away fundamental rights and freedoms. The constant threat of violence, along with the restrictions on movement imposed by blockades and extreme violence, infringes upon fundamental human rights, fostering a climate of fear and insecurity. There has also been overwhelming loss of life, trauma, and insecurity disrupting the daily lives of people. The impacts are far-reaching.

The conflict underscores the urgent need for a resolution that respects the civil rights of all individuals involved. Achieving peace and justice requires acknowledging the humanity and rights of both Palestinians and Israelis, fostering dialogue, and working toward solutions that promote equality, security, and dignity for everyone. We must be reminded of the importance of navigating conflict while celebrating our differences and fostering mutual respect. Despite the turmoil, there lies a profound opportunity for us to come together, recognizing that our diverse cultures and faiths enrich the tapestry of our shared humanity. By embracing these differences with empathy and understanding, we can build bridges of peace and solidarity. Acknowledging the fundamental principles of civil rights and social justice, we must commit to protecting the dignity and rights of every individual, regardless of their background. Let us honor this moment by reaffirming our dedication to harmony, equity, and respect for all, ensuring a future where every person is valued and justice prevails.

Call to Action: For more information visit the ABA’s Task Force to Combat Antisemitism and Task Force to Combat Islamophobia webpages to learn how you can support efforts to protect human rights, or you can sign up to be involved in our International Human Rights Committee

Your engagement with these topics, our initiatives and programming is not just beneficial but essential. By staying informed and taking action, we can collectively drive significant progress.

Together, let's be the catalysts for change.

Best regards,

Lacy L. Durham

    Author