September 09, 2019

Subcommittee News

From the Cloud and Enterprise Technology Subcommittee

The Cloud & Enterprise Technology Subcommittee will host an open discussion about data.  If you have not read the pleadings in UAB “Planner5D” v. Facebook Inc. and the Trustees of Princeton University, you should.  It raises interesting questions about protecting data collections.  We will use it as a jumping off point for our discussion.

From the Electronic Payments and Financial Services Subcommittee
Stephen T. Middlebrook and Sarah Jane Hughes

While in DC, The Electronic Payments and Financial Services Subcommittee will meet to discuss recent developments in several areas:

  • Congressional Hearings on Facebook’s Libra
  • Litigation over how to classify cryptocurrency purchases on credit cards: Chase and State Farm cases
  • FATF Issues Guidance on Virtual Assets
  • FinCEN Issues Additional Guidance on Virtual Currencies and Money Transmission
  • FinCEN Takes Action Against a Peer-to-Peer Virtual Currency Exchange
  • NY AG Investigates Cryptocurrency Exchange Bitfinex and Related Stablecoin Tether
  • NYC Bar Ethics Opinion on receiving payment for legal services in cryptocurrency (Rule 1.8)

Also, a reminder that we are sponsoring a CLE panel in Washington:

Legal Issues Associated with Wages-on-Demand Products

Friday, September 13, 2:00-3:00 pm

Description:  “Wages-on-Demand” products enable employees to get paid for the hours they have worked without regard for scheduled paydays.  The panel will explain how these services work and address whether these payments are loans or wages, are legally permissible, and what requirements are placed on wages-on-demand services under state law.


  • Alicia W. Reid, U.S. Bank
  • Abbie Gruwell, National Conference of State Legislatures
  • Stephen T. Middlebrook, Womble Bond Dickinson

From the Cross-Border Cyber Regulations Subcommittee
David Flint and Ed Morse

At the forthcoming Annual Meeting in Washington, the Non-US Cyber Regulations subcommittee will meet at 1pm on Thursday, February 12. We will review and discuss developments outside the US that could have an effect on US tech and internet companies.

These developments will include the increasing Balkanization of the Internet with national governments putting in place rules to “protect” their nationals, including:

  • The new Russian legislation promoted by Roskomnadzor to require local DNS routing for users in Russia, with the ability to “cut off” the internet;
  • The “Great Firewall of China”;
  • Kazakh legislation requiring all local ISPs to install a new Certificate in all computers connected to the ISP which would allow Man-in-the-Middle attacks to enable surveillance of all encrypted traffic;
  • New EU Rules on ISP liability for copyright infringement (a great program will look at this in Washington – 10:30 on Friday 13th);
  • UK legislation requiring publishers of “adult” sites to ensure that all users have gone through an age verification system before granting access;
  • GDPR and similar legislation leading to content walls;
  • And many other exciting topics!

It is an ongoing situation and we will have lots to discuss, so come along and share your thoughts and insights.

We are also sponsoring the following CLE panel:

Your Web Content and Diverging Rules in EU and US on ISP Liability for Copyright Infringement

Friday, September 13, 10:30 – 11:30 am

Description: This program will look at new EU Copyright Directive, which presents compliance challenges, including controversial rules in Articles 15 and 17 requiring websites to restrict copyright materials as a condition for immunity from infringement liability.  We will cover implications of the Directive, including comparisons to US law involving fair use and section 230 immunity. 


  • Anupam Chander, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center
  • Corynne McSherry, Legal Director at the Electronic Frontier Foundation
  • David Flint, Visiting Professor at Creighton University School of Law, and Commercial Law Consultant at Inksters, Glasgow, Scotland

From the Smart Contracts and Blockchain Subcommittee
John Ottaviani and William Denny

Please join the Smart Contract and Blockchain Subcommittee for our meeting on Thursday, September 12, at 11:00 am in the Magnolia Blossom Room on the 2nd floor.  We will continue our discussion of  legal and business issues arising from the use of blockchain technology and smart contracts (persistent scripts).   We invite participation from anyone interested in discussing and working on presentations, practice tools, and projects relating to business models, state, federal and international legislation, regulations, governance, privacy, intellectual property and licensing issues in this area.

You also will not want to miss an exciting CLE presentation on Saturday, September 14, at 9:30 am in Salon E-H on the M4 level, titled “Digging Deeper into Blockchain--- Regulatory and Legislative Developments.”   Last year’s presentation was “standing room only” so be sure to arrive early!  


  • Professor Raina Haque, Professor of Practice of Technology, Wake Forest University School of Law;
  • Andrew (Drew) Hinkes, Of Counsel, Carlton Fields;
  • Samir Suresh Patel, Associate, Holland & Knight LLP; and
  • Nelson Rosario, Principal, Smolinski & Rosario Law.

This panel of “Crypto-Lawyer Rockstars” will be moderated by Carla L. Reyes, Assistant Professor of Law and Director of the Center of Law, Technology & Innovation at Michigan State University College of Law.